The case for personal cyber insurance
Here's how prospects and insureds can mitigate digital risk and secure their online lives.
As a professional entrenched in the commercial cyber insurance landscape, I’ve observed an emerging trend around a rising concern that continues to dominate conversations at industry events and webinars: Personal cyber incidents.
Increasingly, we hear about individual cyberattacks, particularly those targeting vulnerable groups like the elderly. These discussions not only highlight the terrifying nature of cyberattacks but also the urgent need for protective measures for those who are least equipped to defend themselves.
While my focus has traditionally been on commercial cyber insurance, I’ve recently ventured into personal cyber policies and claims. Conversations with FBI agents, cybersecurity experts, and my own experiences, have illuminated the critical need for personal cybercrime protection— one that addresses the severe emotional and financial toll it can take.
Personal cyber insurance: The next big thing
The evolution of personal cyber insurance is akin to the establishment of a new safety net for our digital age. Just as fire insurance arose from the ashes of devastating urban blazes and auto insurance became essential as cars transformed our lives, personal cyber insurance is slowly taking shape to meet the demands of our increasingly interconnected world.
However, we remain in the nascent stages. Cyber risk is still evolving, and the policies designed to safeguard against it are maturing.
The word “insurance” itself is derived from the Latin securus, meaning “free from care,” and the French sûr, meaning “safe from danger or harm.” This etymology underscores insurance’s fundamental purpose: to provide peace of mind amid uncertainties.
Today, as we confront new digital threats like data breaches, ransomware and social engineering scams, the necessity for robust, comprehensive protection has never been clearer.
Although some homeowners’ policies offer basic cyber add-ons, they often fall short in addressing the complex cyber risks individuals face. Carriers such as Allstate have introduced ID theft policies, which primarily focus on recovery post-identity theft, rather than preventing or mitigating more advanced cyber threats.
Conversely, companies such as TMHCC offer standalone personal lines cyber policies designed to deliver comprehensive coverage against a wider array of threats.
As the market continues to evolve, the demand for extensive personal cyber insurance will only intensify.
How cybercriminals leverage technology
Scams and trickery have existed throughout human history, constantly adapting to the technology of the time. A striking historical example is Perkin Warbeck, the 15th-century imposter who deceived English nobility by claiming to be the Duke of York. This early form of identity theft illustrates that while methods of deception may change, the psychological vulnerabilities they exploit remain constant.
In our digital age, these age-old schemes have transformed into far more sophisticated cyber threats. Advanced technologies, including AI and the internet, have provided criminals with new tools to deceive on an unprecedented scale, evolving ancient tactics into modern traps. Here are some of today’s most pressing threats:
- Pig butchering scams: Modern scammers utilize social media and dating apps to cultivate trust before convincing victims to invest in fraudulent schemes, only to drain their finances once they’ve gained their confidence.
- Watering hole Attacks: Much like ambushes along well-traveled paths, these attacks infect popular websites with malicious code, compromising any device that visits.
- Malicious apps: Cybercriminals now sell seemingly legitimate apps laden with malware, tricking users into downloading software that steals data or opens backdoors for hackers.
- Social engineering: AI-generated deepfake videos and personalized phishing emails make these scams even more convincing, tricking individuals into revealing sensitive information.
- Deepfakes and real-time data leaks: Innovations in AI have enabled bad actors to impersonate individuals in real-time, creating new challenges for identity verification.
- QR code exploits: The simple act of scanning a QR code can expose users to hackers, transforming a convenient tool into a potential security risk.
These evolving threats use modern technology while taking advantage of age-old psychological vulnerabilities, manipulating trust, feeding on fears, and tapping into desires for security and connection.
A crucial employee benefit
As cyber risks become more personal, we’re seeing a promising trend — the inclusion of personal cyber insurance as part of employee benefits packages. This marks a pivotal step in recognizing cyber protection as essential, akin to health or financial benefits.
However, while this addition provides valuable protection, it’s essential to recognize that such plans may not reach those most vulnerable to cyber threats, particularly retirees who are often excluded from employee benefit coverage.
It’s also important for individuals to closely examine the scope of these policies. Many employer-sponsored plans, while valuable, are often limited in their coverage. They may primarily address identity theft, which is just one facet of the growing cyber threat landscape. Critical risks like ransomware, phishing attacks and reputational damage — which can have devastating personal and financial consequences — are often overlooked.
To fill these gaps, more comprehensive standalone policies are emerging to offer greater protection. The solutions go beyond identity theft to cover a broader spectrum of threats, including financial fraud, ransomware and social engineering attacks.
As these options become more widely available, it’s essential for employees and retirees alike to assess their coverage, ensuring it meets the demands of today’s sophisticated cyber threats.
Practical cyber protection tips
To navigate today’s complex cyber landscape, adopting practical measures for digital safety is vital.
- Establish a safe word. Create a safe word with family and friends to verify their identity during suspicious calls or requests.
- Verify requests. Always call back at a known number if you receive messages asking for sensitive information.
- Be cautious with QR codes: Avoid scanning unknown QR codes or clicking links from unfamiliar sources, as these actions can directly compromise your devices.
- Follow cybersecurity guidelines: Adhere to best practices outlined by organizations like CISA and NIST to protect your home network.
A necessary defense
As personal cyber incidents increase in both frequency and complexity, the need for personal cyber insurance has become undeniable. Coverage options vary widely. Some individuals rely on basic add-ons to homeowners or renters policies while others opt for more comprehensive standalone solutions.
As the threat landscape continues to evolve, I expect significant growth in this coverage area. What shape that growth will take remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Those who prepare now will be far better equipped to navigate the digital threats of tomorrow.
Interested in learning more and taking a deeper dive? You can reach Contributor Katie Pope by sending an email to Katie.Pope@libertycompany.com. She is vice president of Executive Lines at The Liberty Company Insurance Brokers.
See also: