7 cultural issues that drive insurance sales success

Until the appropriate cultural foundation is laid down, no amount of tactical or process-driven solutions will ever make a sustainable difference.

By Kevin Trokey | April 24, 2018 at 06:00 AM
businessman jumping a track hurdle

Sales results are all too often a point of contention for organizations, and insurance agencies in particular. And sales goals are usually some function of just putting out a number to make the accounting department go away.

There is a rarely a plan for how these pretend goals are actually going to be met. Finally, the accountability for following the pretend plan to hit the pretend numbers is non-existent. And yet we still wonder why we rarely hit sales goals.

The gut reaction to missed goals almost always takes us to the tactical/process issues:

• How many calls did you make?

• How many prospects are in your pipeline?

If we truly want to drive more predictable sales results, we have to start by addressing the cultural issues within the organization.

1. Leaders who lead by example – In most agencies, the leaders still have sales responsibilities. If the leaders aren't doing the right things, nobody else will either.

2. Accountability – Every other position in the agency is held accountable for driving their respective results. Because everything is driven off of revenue, producers should be held more accountable than anyone.

3. Have everyone in the right role – I don't care how hard you (or they) try, some people just aren't producers.

4. Properly define success and celebrate the progress – Success in each step of your sales system should be defined as getting the prospect to the next step. Celebrate each of these victories, not just the final sale.

5. Producer confidence – Selling is a transfer of confidence; confidence that you are offering a better solution. But you can't give away what you don't have. Producer confidence is a combination of:

• Being able to take a prospect through a value-driven sales process.

• A full pipeline of prospects.

• Knowing that you have the team and solutions to make a difference for the future client.

6. Proactive versus reactive – We have to do a better job of planning what we will do to drive results, rather than focusing on what has already taken place.

7. Understanding the “why” – Until a producer truly understands his/her motivation, it will be difficult, at best, to keep the proper focus and determination. (Hint: The motivation is never money. It may be what money can allow you to do, but it isn't the money.)

Until the appropriate cultural foundation is laid down, no amount of tactical or process-driven solutions will ever make a sustainable difference.

Which of the cultural issues I've mentioned gives you a sick feeling in your stomach? I'd love to know which one and what your first step will be to address that issue. Just by addressing and answering that question here, you are much more likely to make it happen there.

Game on!

Related: Prospecting techniques: The best of past & present

Kevin Trokey is founding partner and coach at St. Louis-based Q4intelligence, a business, sales and marketing consulting firm working with insurance agencies. Contact him at (314) 436-7171 and check out his LinkedIn profile and follow him on Twitter @kevintrokey.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

By Brittney Meredith-Miller | January 20, 2025

Insurers should leverage all available opportunities to create a premium digital experience.

P&C insurers with the best online customer experience

By Larry Neilson | January 17, 2025

AI is undeniably the shiny new engine under the hood for a lot of marketers.

13 Ways AI moves insurance marketing forward

By Michael S. Fischer | January 06, 2025

These cities are bustling with new businesses, jobs, cultural opportunities — and insurance prospects.

U.S. cities most likely to succeed in 2025
The Future of P&C Insurance: The Race to Contain Costs Amid Rising Catastrophic Losses link

eBook

Sponsored by AgentSync

The P&C insurance sector is currently facing challenges. This eBook outlines the most pressing problems, the most promising solutions, and a few examples of these principles in action.

Revolutionizing Claims Processing: How a Leading Insurer Transformed Water Mitigation Reviews link

Case Study

Sponsored by CoreLogic

Discover how one insurer drastically improved the efficiency of their water mitigation claim reviews, reducing costs and time while enhancing decision-making. Learn how this approach can transform your claims process, making it faster, more accurate, and less resource-intensive.

Distribution Channel Management Assessment link

Assessment

Sponsored by AgentSync

Navigating today’s insurance landscape requires more than instinct. Assess the strengths and gaps in your distribution strategy with this comprehensive tool. Discover actionable insights to refine operations, enhance data quality, ensure compliance, and scale efficiently. Evaluate your current capabilities and see where you stand across five crucial areas. Start building a more resilient and agile network today.