Mentorships are a funny thing—and they seem to be a running theme in my life this month.

My boss and good friend Bill Coffin recently shared with me stories of a wonderful journey he and his family took to Lexington, Va., to visit some of his college professors whom he considered mentors of great influence in his development as a writer and journalist. No longer a student but as a peer, he was able to proudly introduce his wife and kids to them and catch up on a variety of subject matter.

Upon hearing this, I was at once very happy for him and just a touch jealous.

Most of the relationships I've had in which I've been on the supposed receiving end of another's “mentorship” were, for the most part, exercises in learning by negative example. In the early days of my career I worked with mostly at-best-dismissive, at-worst-abusive, insecure superiors who were more concerned with making themselves look better than consciously serving as a mentoring role model.

Which is not to say I didn't learn anything, of course. You certainly learn what not to do: what turns of phrase to avoid, which verbs not to use, what careless grammatical mistakes others make that you will not. One could even argue that a student learns more from a harsh master than a kind one, as any praise granted is always hard-earned and, by that logic, unquestionably deserved.

I've parlayed that pursuit of a very high standard into more journalism awards than most people earn, and that dedication is unwavering. I'm my own worst critic, and there's no question I've come out on the other side a better person for all my experiences.

I have chosen to no longer continue a relationship with the two longtime bosses who helped shape me as a professional; from both I also learned important lessons in how not to treat people—how to exhibit patience but be firm, to encourage potential and help to foster one's talent, and at the end of the day, always give credit where it's due. It's served me well.

There's no question that the insurance industry, or any business, for that matter, greatly benefits from the experience of shared knowledge and mentoring relationships. If both parties allow themselves the gift of accepting the wisdom of another's experience, regardless of age, all of us will always find something new to learn.

The biggest obstacle in making this a reality is not finding but making the time to do so, as so many sources lamented when I spoke to them for my feature on carriers' and agencies' growing need to attract and train more young talent.

Diane Mattis, executive director of InVEST, an organization that works to educate young people in how the insurance industry operates, raised an excellent point as we talked about the industry's need to help cultivate young talent, a journey that inevitably involves mentoring. Perhaps the word “mentor,” she said, is too loaded a term; it somehow conjures images of having a young eager beaver sitting beside you, hanging on your every word—or an investment of time that so few of us can afford in the early 21st century American workplace. Rather, we should think of it as being a “role model” instead, thus removing the formal pretext.

Indeed, leading by example and seizing teaching moments would seem an excellent strategy. And that starts with recognizing your own level of knowledge.

I was recently having drinks with a former colleague and the point came up that until you become a manager or team leader and have to direct others, you often don't realize how much you do know. You spend so many years constantly trying to learn everything you can, regularly beating yourself up because up until now, damn it, you didn't already know the thing that you just learned.

This cycle, of course, repeats itself until the fateful day when you realize that it's now you who's responsible for instructing your charges in how things are done—and suddenly it's your turn to be the teacher.

The question then becomes, will you lead by example and share that knowledge, or leave that task to someone else?

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Shawn Moynihan

Shawn Moynihan is Editor-in-Chief of National Underwriter Property & Casualty. A St. John’s University alum, Moynihan has earned 11 Jesse H. Neal Awards, the Pulitzers of the business press; seven Azbee Awards, from the American Society of Business Press Editors; two Folio Awards; and a SABEW award, from the Society of American Business Editors & Writers. Prior to joining ALM, he served as Managing Editor/Online Editor of journalism institution Editor & Publisher, the trade bible of the newspaper industry. Moynihan also has held editorial positions with AOL, Metro New York, and Newhouse Newspapers. He can be reached at [email protected].