When Dependent Properties Go Dark

Natural disasters often leave many Business Interruption losses in their wake—and Superstorm Sandy will be no different. Businesses that did not sustain damage or were not even closed can still be subjected to losses when other companies with which they do business must suspend operations.

Such is the case for the clients of the FC&S subscriber who sent us the following question:

“We have received a handful of Business Interruption claims as a result of Superstorm Sandy. I have a question as to arrangement and primacy of coverage and how it may affect the interpretation of coverage.

In a couple of claims the insured was outside the main area of the storm; however, the businesses to which it supplies its products were affected by the storm. In general our insured’s policies include an ISO Business Income and Extra Expense form with additional coverage for civil authority. There is also additional coverage with sublimits for dependent properties and off-premise power interruption.

My primary question is centered on the Dependent Properties extension of coverage. In its unendorsed state the coverage part provides business-income loss to our insured because [it] could not deliver its product to the buyer.  However, to trigger coverage there must be direct physical damage to the receiving location by a covered cause of loss. In most cases this did not happen. The receiver closed down due to lack of power or civil authority.

Following the thread, we have two additional coverage parts—Civil Authority and Utility Services— in which the endorsements state that if the insured’s premises is shut down due to either condition, coverage will apply under the appropriate extension.

So what comes first? If I apply the Dependent Properties endorsement first, does that in effect expand the insured’s covered locations from its own to its own and its receivers? If that is the case, I then should be able to apply the Civil Authority or Utility Service coverage extension to the dependent-property locations and in turn provide coverage to our insured for the lack of power or implementation of civil authority at the receiver locations.”

The Civil Authority additional coverage on the ISO Business Income (and Extra Expense) Coverage Form (CP 00 30) provides coverage for loss of business income and extra expenses incurred when an action of civil authority prohibits access to the “described premises.” This coverage is on the insured’s form, so “described premises” means the premises described or listed on the policy declarations page.