Managers and business owners are constantly being harangued to adopt “best practices” and emulate the Warren Buffets and Steve Jobs of this world. But maybe it's time to reverse this trend and learn from the biggest losers.

According to the recently released 2012 American Customer Satisfaction Index, service industries — especially airlines, utilities and banks–generated the worst consumer satisfaction scores, mainly because of limited competition and the difficulty of interacting with customers.

Before you scroll down, know that there's only one insurance company on the list, and it deals with health insurance. But these public-facing businesses generate some of the same types of complaints.

Here are the top 15 most disliked companies:

  1. Long Island Power Authority. Score: 58/100. Gripes: Spurred by losses from last August's Hurricane Irene, complaints include rate hikes and overbilling mistakes.
  2. Northeast Utilities. Score: 59/100. Gripes: After two major storms caused massive power outages last year, hundreds of thousands of customers were left in the dark without heat for up to 2 weeks.
  3. Charter Communications. Score: 59/100. Gripes: Poor customer service and unfair billing practices.
  4. Comcast. Score: 61/100. Gripes: Early withdrawals, faulty equipment and unprofessional service technicians.
  5. United Airlines. Score: 62/100. Gripes: A technical glitch following last year's merger with Continental caused widespread flight delays; complaints include poor customer service, flight cancellations and lost baggage.
  6. Time Warner. Score: 63/100. Gripes: Slow Internet speeds, cable outages, “disastrous” customer service and high rates.
  7. Cox Communications. Score: 63/100. Gripes: Higher rates and fees.
  8. American Airlines. Score: 64/100. Gripes: Ranked last in a recent study of major airlines at keeping customers informed, leaving them on hold for an average of an hour and a half, and failing to respond to questions on Twitter; “does a worse job of pleasing passengers than small, low-cost airlines such as Spirit or Frontier.”
  9. US Airways. Score: 65/100. Gripes: Inaccurate billing, failing to notify passengers of flight delays, and “terrible” service.
  10. Delta. Score: 65/100. Gripes: Most complaints involve customer service reps not responding in a professional manner.
  11. CenturyLink. Score: 66/100. Gripes: Billing issues and customer reps not being knowledgeable or helpful.
  12. Facebook. Score: 66/100. Gripes: Lack of privacy and child safety.
  13. Aetna. Score: 67/100. Gripes: Excessively high prescription co-pays, withdrawing funds without authorization from clients, disorganization.
  14. DirectTV. Score: 68/100. Gripes: “On the Consumer Affairs forum, thousands of customers complaints about how the company changes contract details without notifying customers and therefore, hiking prices without authorization.”
  15. Bank of America. Score: 68/100. Gripes: The nation's largest mortgage servicer, most complaints arise from the mortgage division—although the bank's plan to charge a $5 debit fee was discontinued after 2 months following public outrage.

See a pattern in what they're doing wrong? Here's what I spot:

  • Communication breakdown. If you've ever been on the other end of a call to AT&T (why didn't they make the list?), you know first-hand how frustrating it is to try and communicate with a monolithic business. Voice-mail hell, unresponsive CSRs and setting up public website forums only to ignore the comments they generate are perfect ways to piss off, and ultimately lose, your customers.
  • Size doesn't matter. In fact, if this study is any indication, the bigger the company, the worse the service. This gives the Spirit and Frontiers of the world a nice advantage, so if you're small and able to provide personal attention and service, don't hesitate to use that edge.
  • The blind leading the blind. Customer service reps and other public-facing employees just don't know their jobs at these companies. It's a real lesson to make sure your people are fully trained and prepped to handle any customer situation.
  • They make a bad situation worse. Whether people are suffering in the wake of a major catastrophe or just upset about a much smaller loss, stonewalling them will lose you a customer–and you'll feel their ire through bad word of mouth.
  • No news is bad news. Like those airline travelers stuck on the tarmac for hours wondering what the hell is going on, non-communication in any service industry is a bad idea. Note that a lot of these complaints simply involve not telling the customer the reasons behind the delay, billing increase or contract changes.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.