NU's E&S/Specialty Lines Extra asked wholesalers attending this year's Mid-Year Leadership Forum: What are you doing differently in 2010?
Matt Nichols, president of All Risks Ltd. in Hunt Valley, Md., said 2010 marks a reversal of cautious approaches to hiring and acquiring at his firm.
Looking back on the recent past, he said his firm realized somewhere between late 2007 and early 2008 that growing at the level it had been--25 percent annually over the 15- to 20-year period dating back to the late 1980s--"had a different set of challenges."
"I think everyone went through that--changing maybe a little bit how they hired, altering how long they were willing to give a project, whether it was a hire, a group of hires or an office." Wholesalers generally, and All Risks Ltd. in particular, looked harder at "how long they were willing to allow those projects to continue not making money" throughout 2008 and most of 2009.
Mr. Nichols said the strategy began changing at All Risks Ltd. in fourth-quarter 2009. "The reversal we have had since [then] and into 2010 is really shifting back into high gear with hiring." He added that hiring runs the gamut "from straight out of school [in] our university program, where we hire from insurance-type universities, to hiring seasoned people in the industry."
On that end of the hiring spectrum, he said that "today's environment probably has the best group of people you could look at from a resume experience, with so many people being out of work. So we're aggressively moving into that hiring mode and trying to grow the business organically, something we'd gotten away from over the prior 24 months."
Alan Jay Kaufman, chairman, president and chief executive officer of Burns & Wilcox in Farmington Hills, Mich., said his firm has also stepped up hiring activity. "We have increased our resources in acquiring talent at all levels from college graduates to very experienced brokers."
Mr. Nichols said, in some ways, his firm may benefit from the struggles of competitors in 2010. "So many of our peers out there are making cuts--whether they're looking to sell their operations, or they're looking to pare down because they're owned by a venture capital firm or a bank."
"We're in the fortunate position that we're privately held and still one of the larger brokers in the country, and we're able to continue to reinvest" for opportunities that may bear fruit "three and five and ten years down the road, rather than thinking about simply today," he said.
Asked if the activities of peer firms would prompt All Risks Ltd. to buy any of them outright, Mr. Nichols responded that the group of potential targets is limited. "I think the peers that are cutting back that I would consider are certainly way too large for us to acquire," he said.
Firms that are one-half or one-third the size of All Risks Ltd. "would be the small group of peers that are out there...from a size-of-business standpoint. There's not a whole lot between $500 million and $1 billion in premium--a handful at most. That's the area that we fall in," he said.
"I think that an acquisition would tend to be either a group of people or a small business in a geographic area where we see a fit for ultimate long-term surplus lines business growth," he concluded.
Kevin Westrope, president and chief executive officer of Westrope in Kansas City, Mo., said his firm actually grew about 5 percent in 2009. "That really is a result of just a lot more face time right now," he said.
"Our brokers are traveling heavily and are seeing customers on a pretty regular basis," he said. In addition, "we've always handled our expenses to a level that allows us to keep everybody pretty much employed on a long-term basis," he said.
Mr. Kaufman highlighted cross-selling as a strategy in place at Burns & Wilcox. "We have institutionalized cross-selling in our organization," he said. "Our people now look to make sure that we are writing as much of the available lines of business on a given account [as possible], rather than just a single coverage."
Mr. Westrope noted that his firm entered into the binding authority arena over the last 24 months, with the initial build-out in this segment coming in the states of Florida and California. That was "really an attempt to diversify our revenue stream away from just simply open-market brokerage," he said.
Mr. Nichols said All Risks Ltd., unlike some other firms, already has three premium-producing platforms--brokerage, binding authority and national programs, with roughly one-third of premiums coming from each one.
"Depending on the market, you may have a great opportunity to grow large-account brokerage [or] a great opportunity to grow binding authority," he said. He believes that "today's market is probably most conducive to setting up and driving new program growth."
"We've been particularly focused over the last 12 months on bringing in new programs, bringing in the talent to manage those programs from an underwriting, quote, bind and issue standpoint for our carrier partners, [and] we'll continue that in 2010 where we really push the programs side of the business.
"That gives our brokers, our binding authority people, when they go out and market, something to talk about as a true differentiator--us versus our peers out there, because we've got exclusive products for about 20 different classes of business," he continued.
Programs recently kicked off include an architects and engineers program and a real-estate owned product, he said. The REO product, he said, is one "we had been dabbling in for a number of years, but now we've gone out and hired a full team to run and manage that product. And we've seen significant growth over the last 90 days as the banks have taken on more and more properties that they didn't necessarily intend to own," he reported.
David Price, executive vice president and chief underwriting officer of Burns & Wilcox, observed that "not all of the E&S market is contracting," adding that his firm is focusing on areas of growth such as personal lines.
Mr. Kaufman said, "We are concentrating on product niches where there is less commoditization." Providing an example of a commoditized product, he said "there are dozens of companies that want to write primary general liability, including many in the standard market."
Mr. Price added, "We are delving deeper into our marketing efforts for greater penetration of our agents. We are constantly developing and repackaging new products to meet the needs of the changing environment."
ECONOMY REMAINS SLUGGISH
Meanwhile, signs of an economy recovery that could boost E&S insurance premiums are few and far between in wholesale brokers' offices, these brokers said. They're so infrequent, in fact, that the smallest indication of economic relief produces a round of cheers in some corners--like the processing unit of All Risks.
"You'll hear a yell over there at the desk every now and again that they got an AP [additional premium] audit," reported Mr. Nichols. That is "fairly amusing when you think about it, because that was a significant revenue flow year after year for an awfully long time."
Now "it's an oddity," he said, explaining that the AP audits occur at the end of the policy--"when you actually audit the policy, [the customer] actually owed us money rather than us having to return money or a situation where there was nothing owed one way or another" because their payrolls were higher than they had originally projected.
"An AP audit is something that we did not see for darn near a year" prior to the recent ones that spurred a mini-celebration.
Elsewhere, NAPSLO's insurer and broker members described limited areas of economic recovery--and opportunities for the E&S segment.
"We are encouraged by the slight improvement we are seeing in financial-related problems such as arson, non-pay cancellations, audits returned for collection and decreasing exposure bases," said Christopher Timm, president of Century Insurance.
Jim Carey, president of Admiral Insurance Company, said, "We have seen strong results in some of our niche segments," highlighting a specialty program for the oil and gas industry as an example of a segment that "has clearly done better than other commercial risks."
Mr. Westrope identified the multifamily apartment house business as an area of the economy that is doing very well. "Occupancy rates on those properties are running fairly high today," he said, speculating that this is a longer-term effect of the mortgage crisis. "Folks who were in houses that maybe were on the margin of whether or not they should have been...are back, and [they] need places to live," he reasoned.
At Mercator Risks in Hartford, Conn., Robert Sargent, executive vice president, said that while economic conditions seem to have improved from a macro perspective, his firm's specialty--professional liability business--"is still seeing signs of distress."
"Businesses continue to reduce insurance buying, revenue and employment levels are not growing, and businesses are continuing to close. We anticipate that some of these signs are lagging indicators, and we are moderately optimistic about opportunities ahead," Mr. Sargent said.
At Burns & Wilcox, Mr. Price said his firm has found success in "tailoring coverage for the [poorer] economic conditions," targeting classes such as vacant buildings and renovation risks.
Mr. Price also noted that with 38 offices in multiple states, Burns & Wilcox has been able to take advantage of the uneven pace of economic recovery, although he did not identify which states were recovering the fastest.
Burns & Wilcox CEO Alan Jay Kaufman identified opportunities for his firm in emerging industries, such as bio-tech, high-tech, alternative fuels and renewable energy.
"We are well-positioned to meet the needs of the burgeoning health care sector," he added. That sector "will be in a high growth mode for many years to come, given the demographics of the United States--longer life spans and aging baby boomers being two key factors."
Mr. Kaufman also said the "trickle- down effects of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Stimulus Package) are starting to show up in certain sectors, such as contractors involved in infrastructure work. As these contractors take on the jobs, they of course need to purchase insurance," he asserted.
Highlighting a final area of opportunity, he said: "Our forte has always been the small-to-medium commercial lines account. This expertise is serving us well as the so-called 'second-stage' companies (defined as having 10-99 employees and $1-to-$50 million in annual revenue) are increasingly the growth engine of the American economy."
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader
Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.