With public entities getting hit by whopping budget cuts while coping with increased liability and added pressure to procure needed coverages, large pooling groups are becoming more and more important for risk managers, one expert in the field contends.
“I would say in the state of California that most, if not all public entities are in a pool of some form or another, whether it be for their property or liability, workers' comp, or even their benefits to some degree, and most if not all have a self-funded component,” said Graham Grice, general manager with Keenan & Associates–an insurance brokerage in Torrance, Calif., that manages most of the state's education pools.
Mr. Grice said Keenan's book of business is mainly in California–the largest pooling state–with a focus on public schools and community colleges. The company manages a number of local pools, some property and liability excess pools, as well as large property and reinsurance liability for regional pools.
Like many states, California is having a budget crisis, facing a deficit of as much as $21.3 billion, meaning that going forward, schools will have even fewer resources, he noted. “People I've spoken to see it as a cut of $600 per student,” he said, adding that “when you consider they get an average of about $5,000 [per student], that's a pretty good chunk.”
A cut in the state budget will manifest itself in many ways, according to Mr. Grice–for example, fewer repairs for an aging infrastructure. “This combined with deferred maintenance will present challenges from their property exposures,” he warned.
In addition, “with reductions in the [public sector] work force, an increase in class sizes and an amalgamation of certain services, I believe we'll see a number of temporary and permanent closures of facilities, which again will increase the [property] risk,” he said, warning that vacant buildings mean more exposures–a big one being arson.
From a liability standpoint, he said deferred maintenance will bring more lawsuits for dangerous and defective conditions in schools and cities, counties and municipalities. He cited, for example, pavements that aren't repaired when they should be, which can result in slips, trips and falls. Such exposures could be exacerbated if budget cuts prompt a reduction in safety services on public property.
Layoffs of public workers could also prompt more suits for employment practices liability–such as wrongful termination involving discrimination, for example, he warned. “We also believe there will be more workers' comp claims filed before the layoffs take effect.”
And for those public entities with risk management departments, he noted, “this will be an area where they really have to fight for their funding.” Budget cuts may mean fewer personnel, with the result being that compliance and training suffer and safety inspections get reduced, he said.
“The mantra that's coming is that yet again, the schools and other public entities are going to have to do a lot more with less resources, like everyone else,” he said.
Overall, Mr. Grice observed, “it's a pretty grim picture.” He noted that from a market standpoint, the vast majority of entities are self-funded, so in terms of additional claims, “the money has to come from tax dollars.”
Participation in pools gives public entities an edge, because they have better buying power to acquire insurance, a greater spread of risk, and access to safety services.
Are public risk managers from small entities losing jobs to pools–which manage everything from purchasing, to claims to training? “I do see this happening some,” he said. “Pools are seen as a way to cut costs and then transfer the costs back to the pool.” He added that while some entities staff their pools, most contract for needed services.
Going forward, public risk managers will be “doing more with less, and this is a trend that will continue,” he predicted. “People will have to be better at allocating their resources, and the squeaky wheel will get the resources.”
Mr. Grice said his company is working on solutions to help clients save dollars–one being an interactive Web-based tool that allows schools and community colleges to do compliance and other trainings online.
The company also rents out safety professionals, so that those school districts or pools without a full-time risk manager can contract with a qualified expert to help them make sure loss control needs are being met.
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader
Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.