Seminal Texas Mold Case Settled

By Michael Ha

NU Online News Service, April 2, 4 :29 p.m. EST?The Texas mold damage case which sent shockwaves throughout the insurance industry with its initial $32 million jury verdict in June 2001, has been quietly settled.

But plaintiff Melinda Ballard said despite the settlement she will continue her advocacy work for insurance policyholders. [@@]

The provisions of the settlement, which was reached late last month, remain confidential and no further information would be made public, said Mary Flynn, a spokesperson for Los Angeles-based Farmers Insurance Group.

Ms. Ballard, whose court battle with Farmers Insurance has now come to an end, said both sides are glad that this dispute is finally settled. "It's always been my position that I would've rather settled than gone to trial," Ms. Ballard told National Underwriter.

"This lawsuit wasn't something I was anxious to get involved with. I've always been willing to settle," Ms. Ballard said. She said she will continue her role as an activist for insurance policyholders nationwide. Her group, Policyholders of America, (www.policyholdersofamerica.org) currently has some 2.5 million members nationwide, she said.

Mark Hanna, spokesman for the Insurance Council of Texas, based in Austin, Texas said the he's glad to see the end of the Ballard case, which had scared insurers and homeowners alike. "It's great to have it behind us," he said.

Mr. Hanna said the settlement agreement is important because the case has been going on for such a long time. "Mold scare ended up costing Texas Insurers more than $4 billion. That case and other media stories about mold is one of the many reasons that we ended up with a crisis in this state," said Mr. Hanna.

Ms. Ballard's case first began as a single claim for water damage to a hardwood floor but was expanded to include mold contamination of the entire house and surrounding structures.

In June 2001, Ms. Ballard and her husband, Ron Allison, were awarded $32 million in their trial against Farmers Insurance, after the jury found that the carrier mishandled the insured's claim for mold damage in their 22-room home in Dripping Springs, an area outside Austin, Texas.

The verdict and Ms. Ballard's allegation of health problems caused by mold drew media attention around the country. But in December 2002, a state appellate court lowered the award to $4 million in actual damages, throwing out millions the jury had provided for mental anguish and punitive damages. Last month, appeals were pending at the Texas Supreme Court when both sides reached the settlement agreement.

In an interview with National Underwriter, Ms. Ballard said she is getting tired of being blamed for what she sees as insurers' abuses. "I don't think my case was the impetus for bunch of other mold lawsuits. It just so happened that my case was more publicized," she said. "The real problem is the way in which insurance companies handled claims."

Ms. Ballard also said that as she continues her activist work, her group, Policyholders of America, will launch its own insurance products beginning this summer.

"These products are geared for our group members?they are offered through a major brokerage firm, and we have participating carriers," she said. These products will run the gamut: health, auto, homeowners, she said. "We are excited?it's something new and creative for our members."

But most importantly, Ms. Ballard said she advises her members that embracing preventive measures is the best course. If consumers are better educated on how to prevent expensive claims, she said, all parties involved would be better off. ""I am happy to have educated consumers and I will continue to educate policyholders on ways to prevent these problems," she said. "We will continue with vengeance on our educational efforts."

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.