March 2011 Intro Page

Dec Page

The article of the month that is highlighted in the Dec Page discusses certificates of insurance. Certificates of insurance serve an integral role in the relationship between vendors and buyers, contractors and subcontractors, lessees and lessors, mortgagees and mortgagors, and others who hold interrelated positions in the supply chain of the economy. Most certificates provide only information on the type and limits of insurance that the insured carries, and they have little or no standing legally because they are not contractual in nature. However, certificates do provide those who rely on them with the information needed to verify that coverage exists at the time the certificate is issued and to determine whether it may be adequate for the relationship. For a description and legal implication of certificates, see the designated article in the Bulletins.

The court cases in the Dec Page deal with legal standing, defense within limits provision, and the definition of occurrence.

In the first case, the insurer brought an action alleging legal malpractice against its insured's attorneys. The insurer alleged that the lawyers negligently advised the insured in the negotiation of a high/low agreement, negligently negotiated the form of the agreement, and negligently gave advice regarding settlement. The U.S. District Court in Florida had to decide if the insurer had legal standing to bring such a lawsuit against attorneys hired to defend the insured.

The second case is another U.S. District Court case, this time from Pennsylvania . The court addressed a defense within limits provision in a general liability policy and provided a thorough discussion of that provision, noting that several state legislatures and insurance commissioners have banned or limited the use of the provision.

The final case comes from the Supreme Court of Mississippi. The court was called upon to determine whether the intentional hiring of a subcontractor negates coverage based on whether intentional hiring is or is not an occurrence. The insurer claimed the hiring of the subcontractor was the cause of the property damage and the hiring was intentional and thus, not an occurrence.

The Dec Page also provides information on actions taken by several states over the past year that will affect the insurance industry. Colorado, Connecticut, Iowa, Louisiana, Rhode Island, West Virginia, and North Dakota dealt with laws and regulations pertaining to subjects ranging from how a state court is to interpret a liability insurance policy to cancellation procedures to statutory liens on insurance proceeds.

Questions and Answers

Is the use of a golf cart to pick up mail servicing the residence premises? See Vehicles Used to Service Insured Location. Is removing asbestos floor tiles part of the loss or a separate cause of loss of its own? See Asbestos Floor Tiles Removal. What constitutes the enforcement of ordinances or laws? See Ordinance or Law Enforcement. Inherent defect results in exploding shower glass. See Exploding Glass. What makes a painting a fine art? See Fine Arts and Oil Paintings

Multimedia Liability Policy

AXIS® PRO has developed a multimedia liability policy for any business dealing with cyber exposures. The policy provides coverage for various torts including but not limited to disparagement or harm to the character, reputation or feelings of persons or organizations, interference with rights or privacy, false arrest, and misuse of intellectual property right in content. See AXIS PRO Insurance Policy.

This premium content is locked for FC&S Coverage Interpretation Subscribers

Enjoy unlimited access to the trusted solution for successful interpretation and analyses of complex insurance policies.

  • Quality content from industry experts with over 60 years insurance experience, combined
  • Customizable alerts of changes in relevant policies and trends
  • Search and navigate Q&As to find answers to your specific questions
  • Filter by article, discussion, analysis and more to find the exact information you’re looking for
  • Continually updated to bring you the latest reports, trending topics, and coverage analysis